|
| |
| Essential
Architecture- Search by style
City Beautiful movement |
 |
 |
 |
| Field
Museum of Science and Industry , Chicago. |
Axial plan of
The Mall, Washington, D.C.: the Reflecting Pool and
Lincoln Memorial extend the central axis. |
Capitol building in Denver |
| |
|
|
City Beautiful movement
The City Beautiful movement was a Progressive reform movement in North
American architecture and urban planning that flourished in the 1890s and
1900s with the intent of using beautification and monumental grandeur in
cities. The movement, which was originally most closely associated with
Chicago, Detroit, and Washington, D.C., did not seek beauty for its own
sake, but rather as a social control device for creating moral and civic
virtue among urban populations. Advocates of the movement believed that such
beautification could thus provide a harmonious social order that would
increase the quality of life and help to remove social ills.
History
Origins and impact
The movement arose in the United States in response to inner-city crowded
tenement districts, itself a product of increased immigration and
consolidation of rural populations into cities. The movement flourished only
for several decades, but in addition to the classicizing monuments it left,
it also achieved great influence in urban planning that extended throughout
the 20th century, in particular in regard to the later creation of housing
projects in the United States. The "Garden City" movement in Britain
influenced the contemporary planning of some newer suburbs of London, and
there was cross-fertilization between the two esthetics, one based in formal
garden plans and urbanization schemes of the Baroque the other, with its
"semi-detached villas" evoking a more rural atmosphere.
Architectural idioms
The particular architectural style of the movement borrowed heavily from the
contemporary Beaux-Arts movement, which emphasized the necessity of order,
dignity, and harmony. The movement also borrowed from classical monumental
planning but differed from the true neoclassical style in that in the City
Beautiful movement, the classical idiom was adopted only partially, mixed
with Beaux-Arts elements, and subjugated as means to the end of creating
uniformity and harmony in style.
World Columbian Exposition
The first large-scale elaboration of the City Beautiful is considered to
have been the "White City", as it came to be called, at the World Columbian
Exposition of 1893 in Chicago. The planning of the exposition was headed by
architect Daniel Burnham, who brought in architects from the eastern United
States, as well as the sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens, to build large-scale
Beaux-Arts monuments that were vaguely classical with uniform cornice
height. The exposition displayed a model city of grand scale, with clean
state-of-the-art transport systems and no visible poverty. The exposition is
credited with leading to the wide-scale embrace of the monumental idiom in
American architecture for the next 15 years. Richmond, Virginia's Monument
Avenue is one expression of this initial movement.
Louisiana Purchase Exposition
The momentum begun by the World Columbian Exposition was accelerated at the
Louisiana Purchase Exposition in St. Louis. In 1901 the commissioner of
architects selected Franco-American architect Emmanuel Louis Masqueray to be
Chief of Design of the Fair. In this position, which Masqueray held for
three years, he designed the following Fair buildings in the prevaling Beaux
Arts mode: Palace of Agriculture, the Cascades and Colonnades, Palace of
Forestry, Fish, and Game, Palace of Horticulture and Palace of
Transportation, all of which were widely emulated in civic projects across
the United States. Masqueray resigned shortly after the fair opened in 1904,
having been invited by Archbishop John Ireland of St. Paul to come to
Minnesota and design a new cathedral for the city in the Fair's Beaux Arts
style. Other celebrated architects of the Fair's buildngs, notably Cass
Gilbert (who designed the Saint Louis Art Museum, originally the Fair's
Palace of the Fine Arts), similarly employed the City Beautiful ideas from
the Fair throughout their life's work.
McMillan Plan
An early use of the City Beautiful ideal with intent of creating social
order through beautification was the McMillan Plan, named for the Michigan
Senator James McMillan, which arose from the Senate Park Commission's
redesign of the monumental core of Washington, D.C. to commemorate the
city's centennial and to fulfill unrealized aspects of the city plan of
Pierre Charles L'Enfant a century earlier.
The Washington planners, who included Burnham, Saint-Gaudens, Charles McKim
of McKim, Mead, and White, and Frederick Law Olmsted, Jr., visited many of
the great cities of Europe with the intent of putting Washington on par with
the European capitals of the era and creating a sense of the legitimacy of
government in a time of social upheaval in the United States. The essence of
the plan surrounded the U.S. Capitol with monumental government buildings to
replace "notorious slum communities". At the heart of the design was the
creation of the National Mall and eventually included Burnham's Union
Station. The implementation of the plan was interrupted by World War I but
resumed after the war, culminating in the construction of the Lincoln
Memorial in 1922.
Influence in other cities
The movement's success in Washington is credited with influencing subsequent
plans for beautification in many other cities, including Chicago, Cleveland,
Columbus, Montreal, Denver, Madison (with the axis from the capitol building
through State Street and to the University of Wisconsin campus), New York
City (notably the Manhattan Municipal Building), Pittsburgh (the Schenley
Farms district in the Oakland neighborhood of parks, museums, and
universities), and San Francisco (manifested by its Civic Center). In New
Haven, John Russell Pope drew up a plan for Yale University that swept away
substandard housing, but banished the urban poor to the peripheries.
Denver
In Denver the energy behind extensive City Beautiful planning came from
Mayor Robert W. Speer, whose plan centered round a Civic Center, disposed
along a grand esplanade that led to the Colorado State Capitol. The plan was
partly realized, on a reduced scale, with the Greek amphitheater, Voorhies
Memorial and the Colonnade of Civic Benefactors, completed in 1919. The
Andrew Carnegie Foundation funded the Denver Public Library (1910), which
was designed as a three-story Greek Revival temple with a colossal Ionic
colonnade across it front; inside it featured open shelves, an art gallery
and a children's room. Monuments capping vistas were an essential feature of
City Beautiful urban planning: in Denver Paris-trained American sculptor
Frederick MacMonnies was commissioned to design a monument marking the end
of the Smoky Hill Trail. The bronze Indian guide he envisaged was vetoed by
the committee and replaced with an equestrian Kit Carson.
Notes
^ Daniel M. Bluestone, Columbia University, (September 1988).Detroit's City
Beautiful and the Problem of Commerce Journal of the Society of
Architectural Historians, Vol. XLVII, No. 3, pp. 245-62.
|
| |
|